Many mickles make a muckle. What the heck does that mean? Well, it’s an archaic phrase meaning many small things add up to one big thing. In this episode of Street Shots, the Switch to Manual guys discuss all the small things photographer Steve McCurry has done lately to put himself in one big mess. Is he a photojournalist or a “visual storyteller?” Does it really matter, with all that’s going on in the world, that McCurry has been “caught” altering his images using Photoshop? Who’s it harming? Is he a phoney? Well, the STM guys raise some of these questions in the hope that we can all learn something about what it means to be a photographer in these days of chasing “likes” and the siren song of image manipulation software.
This is the Green-Wood Cemetery image that was discussed. The first is Tom’s unaltered interpretation of the scene. The second image is Antonio’s interpretation. It’s interesting how we project our own ideals into the work of others. We posted this to show just how a retoucher or printer can alter a scene originally shot by someone else. Sometimes it’s a great job, sometimes it’s not and the Internet catches you.